I don’t believe that tests per se (written questions to be answered), are the only objective way to assess student learning. As a musician and music teacher, I suppose the performances of my students could be called tests for both the students and my instructional technique, but I prefer to think of them as an alternative assessment. When we perform, it is either considered particular levels of “correct,” or “incorrect.” Though it is a concrete assessment of whether or not we perform “well,” the further listening by a musician or an adjudicator would reveal the more subjective aspects of the performance.
As a final reflection, I think that all assessments are really tests of one sort or another. If we assess knowledge, techniques and execution in any aspect of school or life, I think we are really testing. Even when the doctor looks in my mouth with a tongue depressor, he is making an assessment of what he sees based on knowledge he or she has gained over the career, and thus they are performing a test of sorts. This is an interesting topic to explore, and I think I will need to research this topic more, and further develop my opinion on this matter. Thank you for reading!
Don Pearce